1986 Kristin Friedholm (second team)
  Lesli Allison (second team)
1987 Kristin Friedholm (second team)
  Lesli Allison (second team)
1988 Kristin Friedholm (second team)
1989 Lynn Murphy (second team)
  Kristin Friedholm (honorable mention)
1990 Anne Gamache (second team)
  Molly Sellner (honorable mention)
  Susan Kerr (honorable mention)
1991 Rachel Barney (second team)
  Anne Gamache (second team)
  Molly Sellner (honorable mention)
1992 Anne Gamache (first team)
  Trisha Cunanne (second team)
  Rachel Barney (second team)
  Molly Sellner (honorable mention)
1993 Trisha Cunnane (second team)
  Kim Halamar (honorable mention)
  Diana Howansky (honorable mention)
1994 Rachel Barney (honorable mention)
1995 Liz Cheung (second team)
  Tosh Forde (honorable mention)
1996 Tosh Forde (second team)
  Ali Ahern (honorable mention)
  Liz Cheung (honorable mention)
  Kriszen Williams (honorable mention)
1997 Liz Cheung (first team)
1998 Logan Coyle (second team)
  Kerry Martin (second team)
  Ali Ahern (honorable mention)
  Katie Gifford (honorable mention)
1999 Logan Coyle (second team)
  Jessica Haftek (second team)
  Kerry Martin (second team)
2000
 Meredith Corkery (honorable mention)
  Logan Coyle (honorable mention)
2001 Tara Davis (first team)
  Lauren Papalia (first team)
  Jessica Haftek (second team)
  Meredith Corkery (honorable mention)
  Brianne Pardini (honorable mention)
  Jana Whiting (honorable mention)
2002 Tara Davis (second team)
  Meredith Corkery (honorable mention)
  Eva Gudbjornsdottir (honorable mention)
  Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention)
  Brianne Pardini (honorable mention)
2003 Jana Whiting (second team)
  Erica Woda (second team)
  Shannon Munoz (honorable mention)
  Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention)
2004
 Shannon Munoz (second team)
  Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention)
  Meghan Hurlbut (honorable mention)
2005 Meghan Hurlbut (second team)
  Jana Whiting (second team)
  Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention)
  Cassie Hamar (honorable mention)
  Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention)
2006 Shannon Munoz (first team, Ivy League Player of the Year)
  Emma Judkins (first team)
  Bailey Schroeder (first team)
  Allison Vespa (first team)
  Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention)
  Cassie Hamar (honorable mention)
  Meghan Hurlbut (honorable mention)
2007 Cathleen Cimino (first team)
  Sophie Reiser (first team)
  Lindsey Knowles (honorable mention)
  Allison Vespa (honorable mention)
2008 Sophie Reiser (first team, Ivy League Player of the Year)
  Meggie Ford (second team)
  Ashley Mistele (second team)
  Rebecca Taylor (second team)
  Ashlin Yahr (second team)
  Lauren Cooke (honorable mention)
2009 Sophie Reiser (first team)
  Ashley Mistele (second team)
  Ashlin Yahr (second team)
  Meggie Ford (honorable mention)
  Chrissy Butler (honorable mention)
2010 Ashlin Yahr (first team)
  Lauren Cooke (second team)
  Lillian Klein (honorable mention)
  Chelsea Ryan (honorable mention)
  Liz Wicks (honorable mention)
2011 Liz Wicks (second team)
  Lillian Klein (honorable mention)
  Ashlin Yahr (honorable mention)