| 1960 |
Hert Buehler (first team)
|
1962
|
Samson Jemie (first team)
|
|
Steve Robinson (first team)
|
1963
|
Donatus Anyanwu (first team)
|
1964
|
Steve Robinson (first team)
|
1966
|
Dick Andrews (first team)
|
|
Mossik Hacobian (first team)
|
| 1968 |
Rocco Commisso (second team) |
1969
|
Len Renery (first team)
|
| |
Rocco Commisso (second team) |
1970
|
Len Renery (first team)
|
|
Omar Chamma (second team)
|
|
Steve Low (second team)
|
|
Mike Vorkas (second team)
|
| |
Rocco Commisso (honorable mention) |
1971
|
Steve Low (second team)
|
|
Pete Vasudhara (second team)
|
1972
|
Manny Osode (honorable mention)
|
1973
|
Pete Vasudhara (second team)
|
|
Tony Fowler (honorable mention)
|
|
Steve Kaplan (honorable mention)
|
1974
|
Tony Fowler (first team)
|
|
Miguel Fernandez (second team)
|
1975
|
Fred Sock (second team)
|
|
Gus Cerri (honorable mention)
|
|
Cliff Sims (honorable mention)
|
1976
|
Gus Cerri (second team)
|
|
Cliff Sims (honorable mention)
|
|
Leo Stillitano (honorable mention)
|
1977
|
Fred Sock (first team)
|
|
Peter Kovalenko (second team)
|
|
Ed Triana (second team)
|
|
Shahin Shayan (honorable mention)
|
|
Cliff Sims (honorable mention)
|
1978
|
Steve Charles (first team)
|
|
Barry Nix (first team)
|
|
Shahin Shayan (first team)
|
|
Tommy Panayotidi (second team)
|
|
John McElaney (honorable mention)
|
|
Kurt Swanbeck (honorable mention)
|
|
Giovanni Vitale (honorable mention)
|
|
Todd White (honorable mention)
|
1979
|
Steve Charles (first team)
|
|
John McElaney (first team)
|
|
Barry Nix (first team)
|
|
Shahin Shayan (first team)
|
|
Kurt Swanbeck (honorable mention)
|
|
Giovanni Vitale (honorable mention)
|
1980
|
Barry Nix (first team)
|
|
Steve Sirtis (first team)
|
|
Steve Pratten (second team)
|
|
Kurt Swanbeck (second team)
|
|
Giovanni Vitale (second team)
|
|
Steve Casiano (honorable mention)
|
|
Todd White (honorable mention)
|
1981
|
Barry Nix (first team)
|
|
Steve Pratten (first team)
|
|
Steve Sirtis (first team)
|
|
Solomon Gayle (second team)
|
|
Gary Escher (honorable mention)
|
|
Kazbek Tambi (honorable mention)
|
|
Todd White (honorable mention)
|
1982
|
Amr Aly (first team)
|
|
Steve Pratten (first team)
|
|
Steve Sirtis (first team)
|
|
Solomon Gayle (second team)
|
|
Kazbek Tambi (second team)
|
|
John Meegan (honorable mention)
|
|
Dexter Skeene (honorable mention)
|
|
Greg Varney (honorable mention)
|
1983
|
Amr Aly (first team)
|
|
Neil Banks (first team)
|
|
Gary Escher (first team)
|
|
Solomon Gayle (first team)
|
|
Steve Sirtis (first team)
|
|
Greg Varney (first team)
|
|
Steve Pratten (second team)
|
|
Dexter Skeene (second team)
|
|
Kevin McCarthy (honorable mention) |
|
John Meegan (honorable mention)
|
|
Mark Prochilo (honorable mention)
|
1984
|
Amr Aly (first team)
|
|
Solomon Gayle (first team)
|
|
Kevin McCarthy (first team)
|
|
Jeff Micheli (second team)
|
|
Dexter Skeene (second team)
|
|
Jim Wurster (second team)
|
|
James Allard (honorable mention)
|
|
Art Lynch (honorable mention)
|
|
Frank Ozello (honorable mention)
|
| 1985 |
Neil Banks (first team)
|
|
Paul Richardson (first team)(Rookie of the Year)
|
|
Art Lynch (first team)
|
|
Dexter Skeene (first team)
|
|
Jim Wurster (first team)
|
|
James Allard (second team)
|
|
Kurt Dasbach (second team)
|
|
Jeff Micheli (second team)
|
|
Mark Prochilo (second team)
|
|
Kingsley Chin (honorable mention)
|
1986
|
Neil Banks (first team) |
|
Kingsley Chin (first team)
|
|
Kurt Dasbach (first team)
|
|
Greg Bazan (honorable mention)
|
|
Sam DiMaggio (honorable mention)
|
|
Chris Ziadie (honorable mention)
|
1987
|
Kingsley Chin (first team)
|
|
Sam DiMaggio (first team)
|
|
Art Lynch (first team)
|
|
Sigurdur Valtysson (second team)
|
|
Greg Bazan (honorable mention)
|
|
Paul Richardson (honorable mention)
|
|
Chris Ziadie (honorable mention)
|
1988
|
Greg Bazan (first team)
|
|
Nick Ziadie (first team)
|
|
Chris Ahmad (honorable mention)
|
|
Martin Munnelly (honorable mention)
|
1989
|
Oren Pittman (first team)
|
|
Nick Ziadie (first team)
|
|
Chris Ziadie (second team)
|
|
Mike Connolly (honorable mention)
|
|
Peter DiMaggio (honorable mention)
|
|
Sigurdur Valtysson (honorable mention)
|
1990
|
Mike Connolly (first team)
|
|
Peter DiMaggio (first team)
|
|
Oren Pittman (first team)
|
|
Sal Rosamilla (first team)
|
|
Nick Ziadie (first team)
|
|
Michael Griffin (honorable mention)
|
|
Martin Munnelly (honorable mention)
|
|
Sigurdur Valtysson (honorable mention)
|
1991
|
Mike Connolly (first team)
|
|
Peter DiMaggio (first team)
|
|
Oren Pittman (first team)
|
|
Michael Griffin (honorable mention)
|
|
Paul O'Donnell (honorable mention)
|
|
Sal Rosamilla (honorable mention)
|
1992
|
Alon Bolokan (first team)
|
|
Michael Griffin (first team)
|
|
Oren Pittman (first team)
|
|
James Feuerborn (honorable mention)
|
1993
|
Alon Bolokan (first team)
|
|
Rikki Dadason (first team)
|
|
Steve McAnulty (first team)
|
|
Billy Vasiliadis (first team)
|
|
Paul O'Donnell (honorable mention)
|
|
Joe Pesetto (honorable mention)
|
1994
|
Rikki Dadason (first team)
|
|
Charles Balsamo (second team)
|
|
Jeff Traola (second team)
|
|
Alon Bolokan (honorable mention)
|
|
Paul O'Donnell (honorable mention)
|
|
Michael Payne (honorable mention)
|
1995
|
Rikki Dadason (first team)
|
|
Greg Frith (second team)
|
|
Michael Payne (honorable mention)
|
1996
|
Michael Payne (first team)
|
|
Dennis Bohn (second team)
|
|
Matt Napoleon (honorable mention)
|
|
Jeff Traola (honorable mention)
|
1997
|
Tiger Fitzpatrick (second team)
|
|
Anthony Balsamo (honorable mention)
|
|
Rino Matarazzo (honorable mention)
|
|
Matt Napoleon (honorable mention)
|
|
Greg Smalling (honorable mention)
|
1998
|
Rino Matarazzo (first team)
|
|
Greg Smalling (second team)
|
|
Anthony Balsamo (honorable mention)
|
|
Tiger Fitzpatrick (honorable mention)
|
1999
|
Tiger Fitzpatrick (second team)
|
|
Matt Hill (second team)
|
|
David Duffy (honorable mention)
|
|
Soroosh Seyhoon (honorable mention)
|
2000
|
Tiger Fitzpatrick (first team)
|
|
David Duffy (second team)
|
|
Matt Hill (second team)
|
|
Leo Matarazzo (honorable mention)
|
|
Tommy McMenemy (honorable mention)
|
2001
|
Stephen Foster (first team)
|
|
David Duffy (second team)
|
|
Michael Ching (honorable mention)
|
|
David Lagasse (honorable mention)
|
2002
|
Tommy McMenemy (first team)
|
|
David Duffy (second team)
|
|
Blake Lindberg (second team)
|
|
Michael Ching (honorable mention)
|
|
Jon Mycroft (honorable mention)
|
2003
|
Tommy McMenemy (first team)
|
|
Dean Arnaoutakis (second team)
|
|
Sekou Cox (second team)
|
|
Stephen Foster (second team)
|
|
Blake Lindberg (second team)
|
|
Gui Stampur (honorable mention)
|
2004
|
Thorsteinn Gestsson (first team)
|
|
Blake Lindberg (second team)
|
|
John Mulhern (honorable mention)
|
2005
|
Sekou Cox (second team)
|
|
Tom Heinbockel (second team)
|
|
Blake Lindberg (second team)
|
|
John Mulhern (second team)
|
2006
|
Tom Davison (second team)
|
|
John Mulhern (second team)
|
|
Tom Heinbockel (honorable mention) |
| 2007 |
Tom Heinbockel (second team)
|
| 2008 |
Bayo Adafin (second team) |
| |
Peppe Carotenuto (honorable mention) |
| 2009 |
Bayo Adafin (honorable mention) |
| 2010 |
Henning Sauerbier (second team) (Rookie of the Year)
|
| |
Mike Mazzullo (honorable mention) |
| |
David Najem (honorable mention) |
| |
Ronnie Shaban (honorable mention) |
| 2011 |
Will Stamatis (first team) |
| |
Mike Mazzullo (second team) |
| |
David Najem (second team) |
| |
Henning Sauerbrier (second team) |
| |
Ronnie Shaban (second team) |
| |
Nick Scott (second team) |
