1870
Captain Stuyvesant Fish
Opponent Score
Rutgers L3-6

(0-1)


1871
Captain  Robert Arnold
(no games played)


1872
Captain  Alex B. Simonds
Opponent Score
Rutgers  T0-0
Rutgers  L5-7
Yale L0-3
Stevens  W6-0

(1-2-1)


1873
Captain Charles King
Opponent Score
Stevens  W2-1
Rutgers L4-5
Rutgers W4-3

(2-1)


1874
Captain Charles King
Opponent Score
Rutgers L1-6
Stevens L2-4
Rutgers W4-1
Princeton L0-6
Yale L1-5
Yale L1-6

(1-5)


1875
Captain Edward W. Price
Opponent Score
Rutgers T1-1
Stevens W2-1
CCNY W5-0
Princeton L2-6
CCNY W6-0
Yale W3-2

(4-1-1)


1876
Captain Edward W. Price
Opponent Score
Stevens  L3-5
Princeton L0-3
Stevens  W4-0
Yale L0-2

(1-3)


1877
Captain Chas. DeH. Bower
Opponent Score
Harvard L0-6G,9T
Rutgers W6T-0
Princeton L3T-4G,6T

(1-2)


1878
Captain Augustus I. Burton
Opponent Score
Penn T0-0

(0-0-1)


1879
Captain William F. Morgan
Opponent Score
Stevens T0-0
Princeton L0-2G,3T
Penn L0-1T
Yale L0-2G,3T
Rutgers  T0-0

(0-3-2)


1880
Captain Frederick A. Potts
Opponent Score
Harvard L0-3G,1T
Yale L0-13G,3T
Rutgers  W3G-3T

(1-2)


1881
Captain B.P. Clark
Opponent Score
Stevens  3G-1G,1TW,2S
Harvard 0-1G-3TL
Rutgers 1S-4ST
Princeton 3S-1G,2T,2SL
Yale 6S-1GL
Rutgers 1G-3SW,3T
Penn 2G-0W

(3-3-1)


1882
Captain B.P. Clark
Opponent Score
Princeton L0-8G,3T
Rutgers L1T-2G,1T
Harvard L0-2G,4T
Yale L0-11G,4T
Princeton L0-3G,1T

(0-5)


1883
Captain W.N. Eldridge
Opponent Score
CCNY W12-0
Stevens L0-19
Penn L1-35
Yale L0-93

(1-3)


1884
Captain Charles A. Stevens
Opponent Score
Rutgers L5-35
CCNY W16-0

(1-1)


1885
Captain Wm. A. Meikleham
(no games played)


1886-1888
no teams


1889
Captain J.M. Hewlett
Opponent Score
Crescent L0-30
Lafayette T10-10
Trinity L4-24
Yale L0-62
Lehigh L6-51
Princeton L0-71
Penn L0-24
Stevens W12-6
Manhattan AC W22-0
Amherst T0-0
Cornell L0-20

(2-7-2)


1890
Captain A.C. Gildersleeve
Opponent Score
Wesleyan L0-4
Penn L0-18
Fordham W40-0
Crescent L0-29
Princeton L0-85
Rutgers T6-6
Cornell L0-36

(1-5-1)


1891
Captain T. Ludlow Chrystie
Opponent Score
Berkeley AC W32-0
Manhattan AC L0-28
Crescent L0-42
Stevens  L0-52
Trinity L0-54
Rutgers L0-44

(1-5)


1892-1898
No games played.
   
1893
Captain H.H. Armstead
   
1894
Captain T.H. Joseph
   
1895
Captain E.S. Moffatt, Jr.


1899-1901 George F. Sanford


1899
Captain Robert R. Wilson
Opponent Score
Rutgers W26-0
Union W21-0
Princeton L0-11
NYU W40-0
Amherst W18-0
Yale W5-0
Stevens  W46-0
Cornell L0-39
Army W16-0
Dartmouth W22-0
Carlisle L0-45

(8-3)


1900
Captain William R. Morley
Opponent Score
Rutgers W11-0
Wesleyan W12-0
Williams T0-0
Harvard L0-24
Stevens W45-0
Penn L0-30
Yale L5-12
Princeton W6-5
Buffalo W17-0
Navy W11-0
Carlisle W17-6

(7-3-1)