1904-05 Harry Fisher
  Marcus Hurley
1905-06 Marcus Hurley
1906-07 Marcus Hurley
  S. Melitzer
  J.J. Ryan
1907-08 W.A. Kimbel
  J.J. Ryan
  Ted Kiendl (second team)
  S. Melitzer (second team)
1908-09 B.P. Cerussi
  Ted Kiendl
  W.A. Kimbel
  S. Melitzer
  J.J. Ryan
1910-11 A.D. Alexander
  Ted Kiendl
  W.M. Lee
  R.V. Mahon
  Claus Benson (second team)
1911-12 Claus Benson
  E.H. Osterhout
  Dan Meehan (second team)
1912-13 S. Jacques
1913-14 R. Benson (second team)
  Dan Meehan (second team)
1914-15 Charlie Lee
1920-21 James Johnson (second team)
1922-23 Samuel Strom (second team)
1923-24 R.J. Kirchmeyer (second team)
1924-25 H.C. Wilson (second team)
1925-26 William Laub
  W.A. Mannheim
  Jack Rothenfeld
1926-27 John Lorch
1928-29 George Gregory
  Arthur Smith
1929-30 Lou Bender
  George Gregory
  Don Magurk
  Sam Schoenfeld
1930-31 Lou Bender
  George Gregory
  Dave Jones
1931-32 Lou Bender
  Dave Jones
1932-33 Leonard Hartman
1934-35 Bill Nash
1935-36 Jim Casey
  Bill Nash
  C. Wolf
1936-37 John O'Brien
1937-38 John O'Brien
1940-41 Bill Hasslinger
1944-45 Norm Skinner
1946-47 Walt Budko
1947-48 Walt Budko
  Sherry Marshall
1949-50 John Azary
1950-51 John Azary
  Jack Molinas (second team)
  Bob Reiss (second team)
  Al Stein (second team)
  Thomas Powers (hon. mention)
1951-52 Al Stein
  Bob Reiss (second team)
1952-53 Jack Molinas