| 1986 |
Kristin Friedholm (second team)
|
| |
Lesli Allison (second team)
|
| 1987 |
Kristin Friedholm (second team)
|
| |
Lesli Allison (second team) |
| 1988 |
Kristin Friedholm (second team)
|
| 1989 |
Lynn Murphy (second team)
|
| |
Kristin Friedholm (honorable mention)
|
| 1990 |
Anne Gamache (second team)
|
| |
Molly Sellner (honorable mention) |
| |
Susan Kerr (honorable mention) |
| 1991 |
Rachel Barney (second team)
|
| |
Anne Gamache (second team)
|
| |
Molly Sellner (honorable mention) |
| 1992 |
Anne Gamache (first team)
|
| |
Trisha Cunanne (second team) |
| |
Rachel Barney (second team) |
| |
Molly Sellner (honorable mention) |
| 1993 |
Trisha Cunnane (second team)
|
| |
Kim Halamar (honorable mention) |
| |
Diana Howansky (honorable mention) |
| 1994 |
Rachel Barney (honorable mention)
|
| 1995 |
Liz Cheung (second team)
|
| |
Tosh Forde (honorable mention) |
| 1996 |
Tosh Forde (second team)
|
| |
Ali Ahern (honorable mention) |
| |
Liz Cheung (honorable mention) |
| |
Kriszen Williams (honorable mention) |
| 1997 |
Liz Cheung (first team)
|
| 1998 |
Logan Coyle (second team)
|
| |
Kerry Martin (second team) |
| |
Ali Ahern (honorable mention) |
| |
Katie Gifford (honorable mention) |
| 1999 |
Logan Coyle (second team)
|
| |
Jessica Haftek (second team) |
| |
Kerry Martin (second team)
|
2000
|
Meredith Corkery (honorable mention) |
| |
Logan Coyle (honorable mention) |
| 2001 |
Tara Davis (first team)
|
| |
Lauren Papalia (first team) |
| |
Jessica Haftek (second team) |
| |
Meredith Corkery (honorable mention) |
| |
Brianne Pardini (honorable mention) |
| |
Jana Whiting (honorable mention) |
| 2002 |
Tara Davis (second team)
|
| |
Meredith Corkery (honorable mention) |
| |
Eva Gudbjornsdottir (honorable mention) |
| |
Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention) |
| |
Brianne Pardini (honorable mention) |
| 2003 |
Jana Whiting (second team)
|
| |
Erica Woda (second team) |
| |
Shannon Munoz (honorable mention) |
| |
Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention) |
2004
|
Shannon Munoz (second team)
|
| |
Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention) |
| |
Meghan Hurlbut (honorable mention) |
| 2005 |
Meghan Hurlbut (second team)
|
| |
Jana Whiting (second team) |
| |
Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention) |
| |
Cassie Hamar (honorable mention) |
| |
Courtney Nasshorn (honorable mention) |
| 2006 |
Shannon Munoz (first team, Ivy League Player of the Year)
|
| |
Emma Judkins (first team) |
| |
Bailey Schroeder (first team) |
| |
Allison Vespa (first team) |
| |
Cathleen Cimino (honorable mention) |
| |
Cassie Hamar (honorable mention) |
| |
Meghan Hurlbut (honorable mention) |
| 2007 |
Cathleen Cimino (first team)
|
| |
Sophie Reiser (first team) |
| |
Lindsey Knowles (honorable mention) |
| |
Allison Vespa (honorable mention) |
| 2008 |
Sophie Reiser (first team, Ivy League Player of the Year) |
| |
Meggie Ford (second team) |
| |
Ashley Mistele (second team) |
| |
Rebecca Taylor (second team) |
| |
Ashlin Yahr (second team) |
| |
Lauren Cooke (honorable mention) |
| 2009 |
Sophie Reiser (first team) |
| |
Ashley Mistele (second team) |
| |
Ashlin Yahr (second team) |
| |
Meggie Ford (honorable mention) |
| |
Chrissy Butler (honorable mention) |
| 2010 |
Ashlin Yahr (first team) |
| |
Lauren Cooke (second team) |
| |
Lillian Klein (honorable mention) |
| |
Chelsea Ryan (honorable mention) |
| |
Liz Wicks (honorable mention) |
| 2011 |
Liz Wicks (second team) |
| |
Lillian Klein (honorable mention) |
| |
Ashlin Yahr (honorable mention) |
